top of page

The Map That Still Shapes Charlotte

Oct 14
6 min read

Written by: Krisha Sharma

Edited by: Samyukta Vivek



Charlotte loves a good old brag. It continues to be one of the fastest-growing cities in the Southeast area. Not only that, but it is also a major banking hub that is  home to a skyline that seems to get taller with each passing  year. But in 2014, researchers studying economic mobility found an alarming statistic that Charlotte was  not as  quick to mention. Among 50 major U.S. cities, Charlotte ranked last for the chances that a child born into a low-income family would ever climb the economic ladder. Shockingly, not bottom ten. Not even bottom five. Bottom. 


The reasons are now revealed to be quite complicated, but part of the story can be traced back nearly 90 years to maps that divided Charlotte neighborhoods by how “safe” they were considered for investment. Places like Myers Park and Eastover were marked favorably. Other neighborhoods were outlined in red and labeled risky, making it much harder for many residents to obtain mortgages and build wealth through homeownership. These practices are obviously  long gone, by 90 years to be exact, but the effects continue to show.


These maps were created by the Home Owners' Loan Corporation, a federal agency created during the Great Depression to help stabilize the housing market. Beginning in the late 1930s, HOLC sent examiners into cities across the country, including Charlotte, and asked them to grade neighborhoods on a four-color scale: green for “Best,” blue for “Still Desirable,” yellow for “Definitely Declining,” and red for “Hazardous.”


Officially, those “grades” measured the city's quality of housing and lending risk. But in earnest reality, residents’ race and immigrant background had influenced how neighborhoods were judged. 

Charlotte contained but a few neighborhoods that received the top green rating. Tom Hanchett, a local historian, named a few: Myers Park, Eastover, then Olmsted section of Dilworth, and a miniature area near Charlotte Country Club, all residing in the wealthier southeast. On the other hand, Black neighborhoods often were given the lowest grades, despite household cleanliness. In other words,  a family could take good care of their home and still live somewhere lenders were warned not to invest. 


For Helen Kirk, this concept isn’t purely abstract. Kirk, then being 94, grew up in a Charlotte she remembered as “quietly, but firmly segregated.” “You couldn't go downtown and eat,” she recalled in a 2024 interview, “Separate bathrooms for Black and white.” Her family's home near Oaklawn Avenue stood in a part of Charlotte that federal examiners had classified as risky. Decades later, when Interstate 77 was built through the area, her family lost their home to it. For Kirk, the neighborhood that federal examiners had once written off as risky became the neighborhood the government chose to pave over, with one policy judgment leading to the next.


Devastating stories like Kirk’s show how housing discrimination was only one element of a larger pattern of decisions that shaped where people could live, how they could build wealth, and whether they could stay rooted in their communities. Hanchett describes the newfound geography in Charlotte as a “wedge of wealth” running south from downtown, surrounded by a “crescent of much less wealth.” These descriptions may sound like relics of the past, but they still hold. Charlotte’s richest neighborhoods remain concentrated in the same direction that drew early investment.


But Charlotte is not an isolated case. A national study by the National Community Reinvestment Coalition compared HOLC's original grades with more recent census data. They found that 74% of neighborhoods once labeled “Hazardous” are still low-to-moderate income today, as nearly 64 percent continue to follow “majority-minority.”Eight decades later, the old maps still bear a remarkable resemblance to the economic and racial geography of American cities.


In North Carolina, researchers found exactly that. A team working with the Environmental Protection Agency compared historic redlining grades with present-day environmental quality in five cities, including Charlotte. They examined factors ranging from air and water quality to land conditions and the built environment, and found that neighborhoods once graded “Hazardous” had significantly worse environmental conditions than those with more favorable grades.


Not every historian agrees that the HOLC maps themselves caused the inequalities that followed. For example, the 2024 Housing Policy Debate paper, Alan Mallach argues that researchers give the maps far too much credit. Mallach found trifling evidence that banks or federal agencies actually used the maps for individual loan decisions. In fact, many “Hazardous” areas were first home to white immigrant families, who were already struggling before the maps existed.


In Mallach’s view, the maps are less a blueprint for inequality than a snapshot of inequality that already existed. He points instead to other causes, such as white flight, the Second Great Migration, and the exclusion of Black families from new suburbs, as major drivers of the racial and economic geography that emerged in the decades that followed.


That does not mean discriminatory housing policy played no role. Other research has found clearer evidence that Federal Housing Administration lending practices restricted access to mortgages and reinforced segregation, even where the direct influence of the HOLC maps themselves is harder to prove. 


The distinction matters, but the two explanations do not have to cancel each other out. No single map or policy explains Charlotte’s divides. While HOLC maps may not have created those divisions on their own, the divisions emerged from a flawed housing system as a whole, one in which federal mortgage policy, private lenders, segregation, suburbanization, and local decisions repeatedly disadvantaged the same communities.


For families like Kirk’s, which policy deserves the blame matters far less than what they lived through: homes lost, communities reshaped, and decisions made for them.


Ten years after Charlotte’s ranking at dead last, the city started to see something akin to true change. When Opportunity Insights, the same Harvard-based research group behind the original study, released new data in 2024, Charlotte had climbed from 50th to 38th among the same 50 major metropolitan areas, the third-biggest improvement in the group. Mecklenburg County stood out in a distinctive way: it was the only county studied where mobility for low-income White children did not decline over the period researchers examined.


The improvement was real, but its causes are harder to pin down. The newer study compares children born in 1978 with those born in 1992, meaning much of that change reflects conditions that shifted long before Charlotte learned of its 50th-place ranking in 2014. Still, this ranking marked a turning point in how the city talked about opportunity. In the years that followed, Charlotte expanded its Housing Trust Fund, a

pproved major affordable-housing investments, launched new public-private partnerships, and created a $250 million Mayor's Racial Equity Initiative, aimed at gaps in housing, education, and employment.


Even the people closest to this work have been careful not to declare victory. Sherri Chisholm, executive director of Leading on Opportunity, said the new ranking is difficult to celebrate fully because many Charlotteans remain in the same circumstances they faced a decade ago.


Helen Kirk is still hoping her neighborhood holds on. When asked whether new policies could help people like her stay in place, she didn't hesitate.


“I hope so,” she said. “I hope so.”





Works Cited


Chetty, R., Dobbie, W., Goldman, B., Porter, S. R., & Yang, C. S. (2024, July). Changing opportunity: Sociological mechanisms underlying growing class gaps and shrinking race gaps in economic mobility. Opportunity Insights. https://opportunityinsights.org/paper/changingopportunity


Idzikowski, S. (2020, May 18). Home ownership and the legacy of redlining: Charlotte's racial wealth gap. UNC Charlotte Urban Institute. https://ui.charlotte.edu/story/home-ownership-and-legacy-redlining-charlottee28099s-racial-wealth- gap


Luben, T., Jimenez, M., Lobdell, D., Krajewski, A., Rappazzo, K., Gray, C., Messer, L., Jagai, J., Nance, D., & Brown, E. (2024, January 2). Association between historical redlining and current environmental quality in five North Carolina cities. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. https://assessments.epa.gov/risk/document/&deid=360051


Mallach, A. (2024, August 21). Redlining maps didn't affect neighborhoods the way you think they did. Shelterforce. https://shelterforce.org/2024/08/21/redlining - maps - didnt - affect - neighborhoods - the - way - you - think - they - did


Mitchell, B., & Franco, J. (2018, March 20). HOLC “redlining” maps: The persistent structure of segregation and economic inequality. National Community Reinvestment Coalition. https://ncrc.org/holc


Murray, K. (2024, March 8). Growing pains: Decades - old “redlining” impacts Mecklenburg County today. WCNC Charlotte. https://www.wcnc.com/article/news/local/black - history/growing - pains - redlining - practices - impact - mecklenburg - county/275 - 6119cc06 - 4648 - 4eed - 987c - 9cd67bbd2814


Sands, A. (2024, July 25). Exclusive: Charlotte no longer “50th out of 50” for economic mobility, new Chetty study shows. Axios Charlotte. https://www.axios.com/local/charlotte/2024/07/25/charlotte - economic - mobility - ranking - chetty

 
 
 

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating

Join our mailing list

Thanks for subscribing!

bottom of page